Benefits - Supervisor
Quick Summary
The Benefits Supervisor supports the effective administration and financial management of the Company’s employee benefit programs. Reporting to the Benefits Manager,
Pay up to $75k + bonus
Great work / life balance
Work from home days allowed
Comprehensive Benefits including 401(k) + Employer Match
10 Holidays Per Year + PTO
What We Offer
~2 min readWe pride ourselves on serving high-quality farm fresh food at Bob Evans! We are AMERICA’S FARM FRESH! We work hard, pay attention to details (perfect plates, perfect bags), and provide our guests with the best, all-around family dining experience. We have immense pride in our culture and roots in our communities.
- Competitive Compensation
- Health and Welfare Benefits
- 401(k) with Company Match
- Flexible Scheduling
- Opportunity for development and career growth
Responsibilities
~2 min readThe Benefits Supervisor supports the effective administration and financial management of the Company’s employee benefit programs. Reporting to the Benefits Manager, this position provides day-to-day oversight of key benefits administration processes, including benefits payroll reconciliation, self-insured plan billing and funding reconciliation, leave of absence administration, and supports annual Open Enrollment.
- →Manage and perform regular reconciliation of employee and employer benefit deductions between payroll, benefit administration systems, and benefit vendor records.
- →Identify, research, and resolve discrepancies involving benefit deductions, enrollment elections, eligibility, retroactive changes, partial pay, refunds, and other benefit-related payroll transactions.
- →Partner with Payroll, HRIS, Finance/Accounting, and benefit vendors to ensure accurate and timely records and processing of benefit deductions and adjustments.
- →Develop and maintain reconciliation processes, reports, documentation, and controls designed to identify errors and reduce financial and employee-impacting issues.
- →Review benefit-related payroll activity for accuracy and escalate significant discrepancies, trends, or control concerns to the Benefits Manager.
- →Provide day-to-day direction, coaching, prioritization, and performance feedback to the Leave of Absence Coordinator.
- →Establish clear expectations and service standards for leave administration.
- →Promote accountability, accuracy, responsiveness, and continuous improvement.
- →Work collaboratively across HR, Payroll, Finance/Accounting, HRIS, Operations, and external benefit partners.
- →Escalate material risks, financial discrepancies, compliance concerns, and employee-impacting issues appropriately. Bob Evans Restaurants, LLC is EEO compliant and participates in E-Verify
- Directly supervise, coach, and support the Leave of Absence Coordinator.
- Provide oversight of day-to-day leave administration and ensure cases are handled accurately, consistently, timely, and in accordance with Company policies and applicable requirements.
- Provide guidance and escalation support for complex leave situations.
- Monitor leave workload, case status, service levels, documentation, and employee/manager communications.
- Coordinate with Payroll, HR, HRIS, benefits vendors, and other stakeholders regarding employee leave status, benefit continuation, return-to-work activities, and related transactions.
- Support administration and compliance associated with applicable federal and state leave programs and Company leave policies.
- Coordinate operational activities associated with annual Open Enrollment under the direction of the Benefits Manager.
- Support Open Enrollment project plans, timelines, testing requirements, communications, and implementation activities.
- Coordinate with benefit vendors, HRIS, Payroll, HR and other stakeholders to ensure enrollment readiness.
- Assist in developing clear employee communications, enrollment materials, FAQs, presentations, manager resources, and other educational materials.
- Coordinate and perform system and plan configuration testing prior to enrollment launch.
- Monitor enrollment activity, troubleshoot employee issues, and coordinate resolution of system or vendor problems.
- Perform post-enrollment audits and reconciliations to confirm elections, payroll deductions, and vendor enrollment files are accurate.
- Strong understanding of employee benefit administration processes and benefit/payroll integration.
- Demonstrated ability to reconcile financial and benefits data and identify discrepancies.
- Strong analytical skills and attention to detail.
- Working knowledge of applicable benefit and leave requirements, including ERISA, COBRA, HIPAA, ACA, FMLA, and applicable state leave requirements.
- Strong Excel and data-analysis skills.
- Experience working with HRIS, payroll, benefit administration, and vendor systems.
- Strong organizational and project-management skills with the ability to manage multiple deadlines and competing priorities.
- Effective written and verbal communication skills with the ability to explain benefit information clearly to employees and managers.
- Ability to handle confidential and sensitive employee information appropriately.
- Strong problem-solving skills and the ability to work effectively across functional areas.
- Bachelor’s degree in human resources, Business Administration, Finance, Accounting, or a related field preferred; equivalent relevant experience may be considered.
- Typically, 5+ years of progressively responsible experience in employee benefits administration.
- Prior supervisory, team lead, or demonstrated leadership experience preferred.
- Experience with benefits/payroll reconciliation and benefit vendor billing strongly preferred.
- Experience supporting self-insured health and welfare plans preferred.
- Experience administering or overseeing employee leave programs preferred.
Requirements
~1 min readThe requirements listed are representative of the knowledge, skill, and/or ability required. Reasonable accommodation may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions.
The physical demands described here are representative of those that must be regularly met by an employee to successfully perform the essential functions of this job. This list is not designed to contain a comprehensive listing of activities, and the employer reserves the right to change or assign other duties to this position.
- Work within typical office environment including sitting for long periods of time
- Office hours may be extended beyond the typical 8-hour workday
- Push, lift, carry and transfer up to 50 pounds
- Reach with hands, use hands for typical office equipment i.e, keyboards, printers
- Use hands to finger, handle, or feel objects, tools, or controls
- Bend and stoo
Location & Eligibility
About this job
- Who can apply
- United States
- Posted
- 11 days ago
Listing Details
- Posted
- October 5, 2026
- First seen
- October 5, 2026
- Last seen
- October 16, 2026
Posting Health
- Days active
- 10
- Repost count
- 0
- Trust Level
- 33%
- Scored at
- October 16, 2026
Signal breakdown
4 other jobs at
View all →Similar Other jobs
View all →Stay ahead of the market
Get the latest job openings, salary trends, and hiring insights delivered to your inbox every week.
No spam. Unsubscribe at any time.