Quick Summary
Handles low to moderate complexity losses, understands and displays a working knowledge and understanding of building materials and construction techniques.
What We Offer
~1 min readAlleviate the impact of adversity during challenging life events by the prompt investigation and resolution of claims. Supports and contributes to the Claims Department and Company’s missions, visions, values, and goals.
- Evaluate files for the accurate and timely reserving of claims in accordance with the Preferred Mutual reserving philosophy.
- Appropriately manage indemnity and loss expenses.
- Conduct thorough and timely investigation to determine liability and claim valuation.
- Treat customers in a proactive and responsible manner
- Adjust schedule as needed to accommodate customer needs and/or fluctuations in work volume.
- Leverage technology as a critical component in achieving efficiencies and delivering superior customer service.
- Handle claims of moderate severity and complexity, with authority up to $45,000
- Display an understanding of avenues of contribution and recovery by third parties and takes appropriate action when necessary.
- Resolve claims promptly and fairly in a manner that is reflective of coverage, liability, and damages.
- Demonstrate an understanding of claim procedures and file administration for proper file documentation and claim reporting.
- Demonstrate an understanding of products and coverages offered by Preferred Mutual;
- Meet file quality standards as determined by internal and external audits.
- Maintain workload in accordance with Key Performance Driver standards.
- Develop an understanding of fraud indicators.
- Recognize Key data points within the claim management and other systems and utilizes the data to make informed decisions and reach better claim resolutions.
Responsibilities
~1 min read- →Handles low to moderate complexity losses, understands and displays a working knowledge and understanding of building materials and construction techniques.
- →Knowledge of all Personal Lines policies and an understanding of Commercial Lines policies with the ability to recognize when additional coverages, endorsements and exclusions may apply.
- →Engages opportunities to build relationships with existing internal/external business partners. Provides a positive customer experience while closely partnering with Independent Adjusters and other stakeholders to deliver an exceptional customer experience on first party property damage claims. Participates in discussions with Marketing and Agency personnel.
- →Thoroughly reviews reports from Independent Adjusters and other vendors to make an accurate and consistent coverage position. Recognizes the steps to take to review an estimate for accuracy.
- →Recognizes appropriate timing and triggers for necessary reserve changes
- →Ability to independently draft basic coverage position letters, identifying most coverage issues and most of the applicable policy citations.
- →Actively identifies and pursues all avenues of contributions and recovery by third parties. Recognizing key pieces of information required to assert a successful Subro claim.
- →Handles litigated or potentially litigated files and coordinates management involvement.
- →Participates in training efforts for new hires and existing staff.
Requirements
~2 min read- High School Diploma or Equivalent
- Bachelor's degree preferred
- 2 or more years of experience in property claim handling and processing
- Progress toward attaining one professional designation preferred (i.e., AIC, CPCU, SCLA).
- Exceptional active listening skills paired with effective oral and written communication skills.
- Make timely, definitive, and fact driven decisions.
- Strong time and project management skills that support continued process improvement.
- Skilled at collaboration, group decision making, problem solving and negotiation. Pursues duties and interactions with integrity.
- Proficient in technology platforms utilized by Preferred Mutual (including but not limited to Windows, Microsoft Office Suite, Outlook, and Internet-based applications).
ABOUT US: As a mutual company, we are independent by nature, so we think about insurance solutions a little differently. Through listening, problem solving, examining your challenges and collaborating on the right solutions for you, Preferred Mutual independent agents provide flexible solutions and adapt to your evolving needs. We do the same for our employees. We are process and domain experts, focused on the solutions that deliver results for our clients and our company. We offer a great work environment, professional development, challenging careers, and competitive compensation. With Preferred, there are no surprises. You can count on us to deliver on our promises and be there when you need us, as your insurance provider and your employer. Preferred Mutual is an Equal Opportunity Employer. Employment decisions are made without regard to race, color, religion, national or ethnic origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, age, disability, protected veteran status or other characteristics protected by law.
DISCLAIMER: This role (job) description indicates in general terms, the type and level of work performed as well as the typical responsibilities of employees in this classification. The duties described are not to be interpreted as being all-inclusive to any specific employee. Management reserves the rights to add, modify, change or rescind the work assignments of different positions and to make reasonable accommodations so that qualified employees can perform the essential functions of the job. Nothing in this position description changes the at-will employment relationship existing between Preferred Mutual Insurance Company and its employees.
The salary range for the role is $62,500-$75,000 per year paid on a salaried basis. The rate offered to any candidate will be reflective of the candidate’s experience and any relevant education, certification, or qualifications related to their ability to perform the responsibilities of this position as permitted by law.
Location & Eligibility
Listing Details
- First seen
- September 25, 2026
- Last seen
- September 26, 2026
Posting Health
- Days active
- 0
- Repost count
- 0
- Trust Level
- 51%
- Scored at
- September 26, 2026
Signal breakdown
Stay ahead of the market
Get the latest job openings, salary trends, and hiring insights delivered to your inbox every week.
No spam. Unsubscribe at any time.